Newton and the Birth of Fluxions
Newton did not invent the derivative by looking at graphs. He invented it by watching things fall. The question that set him on the road was not “how steep is this curve?” but “how fast is this body moving at this instant?” — and once he had answered it for falling bodies, he realised the same question could be asked of any quantity that changes with time, and that the answer was the same object that Leibniz, working independently in Paris and Hanover, was calling .
This page tells the story from Newton’s side. It follows the plague years at Woolsthorpe, when a young Cambridge student shut in the country with nothing but his own thoughts for company; the measurements of a falling body; the moment when the average speed over a shrinking interval stopped wandering and locked onto a definite value; and the notation of dots that Newton used instead of Leibniz’s fractions. It also records the parts of the story that are often told wrongly — the apple, and the priority dispute — and explains why Newton’s calculus, though it came first, was read by far fewer people than Leibniz’s.
Isaac Newton was born on 25 December 1642 (Old Style) at Woolsthorpe Manor in Lincolnshire, the son of a tenant farmer. He entered Trinity College, Cambridge, in 1661, and in 1665 the Great Plague of London forced the university to close. Newton went home to Woolsthorpe, where he stayed for most of the next two years.
Those plague years were the most productive of his life. Working alone, he generalised the binomial theorem to arbitrary exponents, designed the reflecting telescope, worked out the method of fluxions and infinite series, and began the study of gravitation that would eventually become the Principia. What he was doing in all of it was the same thing: measuring change.
About the apple
The story that Newton conceived the law of gravitation while watching an apple fall comes from William Stukeley’s Memoirs of the Life of the Right Reverend Isaac Newton (1752), which records a conversation with Newton in 1726. Newton himself was careful about it, describing the falling apple as a “conjecture” that merely put him in mind of gravity. The documented fact is not that an apple started a chain of thought, but that in 1665–1666, at Woolsthorpe, Newton worked out the mathematics of motion and of gravity. The anecdote is a wonderful story; it is a story, not a record.
The question Newton was chasing was concrete:
What is the speed of a body at one precise instant, when an average over any interval can only blur it?
The average speed over an interval is easy — measure two positions, measure two times, divide. The instantaneous speed is not directly measurable, because “at this instant” has zero duration. So Newton did something clever: he asked what the average speed becomes as the interval shrinks around the instant in question.
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1642 | Newton born on 25 December (Old Style) at Woolsthorpe, Lincolnshire |
| 1661 | Enters Trinity College, Cambridge |
| 1665 | The Great Plague closes the university; Newton returns to Woolsthorpe |
| 1665–1666 | At Woolsthorpe: the general binomial theorem, the reflecting telescope, the method of fluxions, and the first work on gravity and the Moon |
| 1669 | Appointed Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge; writes De Analysi per Aequationes Numero Infinitas |
| 1671 | Writes Methodus Fluxionum et Serierum Infinitarum; it stays unpublished for sixty-five years |
| 1687 | Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica published on 5 July; Book II contains the fluxional notation |
| 1691 | Barrow shows De Analysi to John Wallis; Newton publishes it in revised form in 1711 as Analysis per Quantitates Series et Fluxiones |
| 1703 | Newton becomes President of the Royal Society |
| 1712 | The Royal Society’s Commercium Epistolicum credits Newton with the invention of the calculus |
| 1727 | Newton dies in Kensington on 31 March (Old Style) |
| 1736 | Methodus Fluxionum et Serierum Infinitarum published in Latin translation, edited by William Jones |
Newton modelled free fall with the position function , where is the height fallen in metres and is the time in seconds. He could compute positions exactly, and from positions he could compute average speeds.
| Time (s) | Position (m) | Average speed (m/s) |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | — |
| 1 | 4.9 | 4.9 |
| 2 | 19.6 | 14.7 |
| 3 | 44.1 | 24.5 |
| 4 | 78.4 | 34.3 |
| 5 | 122.5 | 44.1 |
The average speeds are increasing by each second, so the body is clearly accelerating. But no entry in that table is the instantaneous speed at a given moment. Each is an average over a whole second, and an average cannot tell you what happened at one particular instant.
Computing the averages from the table makes the structure clear. Over the first second the body falls m in s, giving m/s. Over the second second it falls m in s, giving m/s. Over the third, m in s, giving m/s.
The numbers are exactly the average velocities Newton would have measured with a falling-body experiment, and they confirm the acceleration. But they still do not give the instantaneous speed at, say, .
Newton shrank the interval. Around he computed the average velocity over the symmetric interval from to s, and then over the much tighter interval from to s.
- From s to s: the position changes by m, over s, so the average velocity is m/s.
- From s to s: the position changes by m, over s, so the average velocity is m/s.
A note on the arithmetic
Many retellings of this experiment report the second average as m/s. That number comes from an arithmetic slip, not from Newton’s method: the correct values are and . The correct average is m/s. There is also a genuine mathematical reason why the two symmetric intervals give the same average: for a quadratic position function the symmetric difference quotient is exactly the derivative at the midpoint, so the answer is already exact for any symmetric interval around .
The one-sided intervals confirm the same limit from each side: over the average velocity is m/s, and over it is m/s. Both straddle and close on it as the interval shrinks.
The average velocity is not “approximating” the instantaneous velocity; it converges to it. That is the insight the whole method rests on.
Now put the reasoning in symbols. For a small increment , the average velocity from to is
Substituting and expanding:
As shrinks, the second term tends to zero, so the instantaneous velocity is
Notice the shape of the argument: it is exactly the algebraic simplification that Leibniz performed on the secant slope of a parabola, with the roles of “curve” and “motion” exchanged. The two men were doing the same thing in different clothes.
Newton gave the method its name. A quantity that changes with time — position, velocity, the amount of water in a draining tank — he called a fluent, because it flows. Its rate of change, the instantaneous speed of the flow, he called a fluxion. The derivative, in Newton’s language, is the fluxion of a fluent.
The notation was built for exactly this purpose, because Newton was thinking about time derivatives specifically. He wrote a dot over a letter for the fluxion with respect to time:
- : the fluxion of position, i.e. the instantaneous velocity.
- : the fluxion of time with respect to itself, which is .
- : the second fluxion, i.e. the acceleration.
For the falling body, . Differentiating once more gives the constant acceleration , which is the famous result that free fall under constant gravity is uniformly accelerated.
- At s: the formula gives m/s, exactly the value the shrinking intervals produced.
- At s: the formula gives m/s, which lies between the averages of m/s (the second second) and m/s (the third second), as it must.
Plot with time on the horizontal axis and position on the vertical axis, and is simply a parabola. The instantaneous velocity is then nothing other than the slope of the tangent to that parabola at the point in question.
- Average velocity = the slope of the secant.
- Instantaneous velocity = the slope of the tangent.
- As the interval shrinks, the secant becomes the tangent.
So Newton’s kinematic question and Leibniz’s geometric question have the same answer. That is the deepest fact in the history of the calculus, and it is the reason the priority dispute could never be settled by examining who did what: they had arrived at the same object by two different routes.
Definition
A definition is a precise description of what a concept, a term, or an object means. Understanding definitions is the foundation of learning any field, and every concept has its own exact meaning.
For a function , the derivative at the point is
- Geometric meaning: the slope of the tangent to the curve at the point .
- Physical meaning: the instantaneous rate of change of with respect to .
Once the definition is written this way, it is completely general. The falling body was only the illustration.
Any law of motion. For an arbitrary position function , the instantaneous velocity is .
Acceleration. Since the velocity of the falling body is , one more differentiation gives : a constant acceleration of .
Planetary motion. The distance of a planet from the Sun is a fluent; its fluxion is the radial velocity and its second fluxion the radial acceleration. Newton’s law of gravitation and the three laws of motion are statements about fluxions.
Optics. The path of a light ray is a function and the law of refraction constrains its slope , so the same derivative serves the optical problems that Leibniz attacked with the same tool.
Extrema. At a local maximum or minimum of a differentiable function, . The second derivative separates the two cases: together with indicates a local maximum, and a local minimum.
Newton’s notation was built for time derivatives and stayed in that channel. A dot over a letter marks the fluxion with respect to time; a second dot marks the second fluxion, a third the third, and so on. So is the first fluxion, the second and the third.
Newton’s dot notation was never intended as a general-purpose notation for differentiation with respect to an arbitrary variable, and he never used an integral sign: integration in Newton’s language was “the method of fluxions inverted”, and he wrote an indefinite integral as a family of fluents rather than with a symbol.
This is the one respect in which the two systems were not interchangeable. Leibniz’s works for any variable pair, and his works for indefinite integration as a general operation. The dots only work for time.
| Newton’s method | Leibniz’s method | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting question | How fast is this body moving? | How steep is this curve? |
| Core objects | Fluents and fluxions | Infinitely small increments , |
| Notation | Dots: , | Fractions and integrals: , |
| Interpretation of the derivative | A rate of change with respect to time | A ratio of infinitesimals |
| Handling of integration | “Fluxions inverted”, no sign | The integral sign, |
| First publication | 1687 (Principia, Book II) | 1684 (Acta Eruditorum) |
Neither approach is “more modern”. The modern definition of the derivative as a limit of difference quotients is closest in spirit to Leibniz’s difference quotient and closest in intent to Newton’s limiting process; it was the synthesis of the two, reached in the nineteenth century, that settled the subject.
Newton’s mathematical work on the calculus was extraordinarily advanced, and almost none of it was published in his lifetime.
- De Analysi was written in 1669 but did not appear in print until 1711, and then only in a revised version.
- Methodus Fluxionum et Serierum Infinitarum was written in 1671 and published in 1736, nine years after Newton’s death, in a Latin translation edited by William Jones.
- The Principia (1687) used the fluxional notation, but only in Book II, and it was a secondary feature of a book devoted to dynamics and gravitation — most readers never noticed it.
The consequence was that the European mathematical public learned the calculus from Leibniz, in Leibniz’s notation, and the English-speaking tradition kept Newton’s dots for well over a century. The Commermium Epistolicum of 1712 — which credited Newton with the invention, and of which Newton himself wrote a substantial part — hardened the disagreement into a national quarrel and made cooperation between the two traditions still harder. The historical verdict, reached in the nineteenth century, is that Newton and Leibniz developed the calculus independently and nearly simultaneously, and that Leibniz’s earlier and more complete publication, combined with his superior notation, is why the calculus in modern form is written in Leibniz’s symbols.
Conceptual. Newton gave the world the idea that a rate of change can be defined as a limit of average rates, and that the same object answers both the geometric question of the tangent and the physical question of the velocity.
Practical. The method of fluxions became the engine of the Principia (1687), from which the mechanics of the solar system, universal gravitation, and much of classical physics were derived.
Notational. The dots are still with us in the language of mechanics, where and are standard notation for velocities and accelerations, even though almost everything else in the calculus uses Leibniz’s symbols.
Exercise 1
Using Newton’s method, compute the derivative of at .
Approach:
Reproduce Newton’s procedure: form the average rate of change over an interval, simplify it, and then take the limit.
Steps:
- The average rate of change is .
- Expand: .
- Simplify: .
- Take the limit: .
- Substitute : .
Answer:
.
Exercise 2
Explain, using Newton’s method of fluxions, why is not differentiable at .
Approach:
Compute the fluxion from the right and from the left separately and compare the two values.
Steps:
- Right fluxion: .
- Left fluxion: .
- The two one-sided fluxions differ, so the two-sided limit defining does not exist.
- Geometrically, is a corner at the origin, and the curve has no tangent there.
Answer:
Because the left fluxion is and the right fluxion is , is not differentiable at .
Exercise 3
Use the method of fluxions to compute the derivative of , and explain its geometric meaning.
Approach:
Apply the same average-rate-of-change procedure as in Exercise 1 to a cubic, then read the resulting formula as a tangent slope.
Steps:
- The average rate of change is .
- Expand the cube: .
- Simplify: .
- Take the limit: .
- Geometric meaning: is the slope of the tangent to the curve at the point ; the slope is non-negative everywhere, and vanishes only at the origin, which is exactly where the curve has its horizontal tangent.
Answer:
, the slope of the tangent to at the point .
Newton’s contribution was to take a question about motion — how fast is this body moving right now? — and answer it by letting the averaging interval shrink until it no longer blurs the answer. The algebra did the rest: the difference quotient simplified to , the leftover term vanished in the limit, and the instantaneous velocity emerged as . The same trick, applied to an arbitrary function, is the definition of the derivative, and applied to a curve it is the tangent slope — which is how Newton’s kinematic question and Leibniz’s geometric question turned out to be the same question. The disputes that followed — over priority, and over whether infinitely small quantities were legitimate — damaged the subject for a century, but the mathematics they produced is the mathematics we still use.
Symbols Used in This Article
| Symbol | Type | Pronunciation/Explanation | Meaning in This Article |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mathematical symbol | s dot | The fluxion of position with respect to time, i.e. the velocity | |
| Mathematical symbol | s double dot | The second fluxion, i.e. the acceleration | |
| Mathematical symbol | y triple dot | The third fluxion of | |
| Greek letter | Delta t | A finite increment of time | |
| Mathematical symbol | s of t | The position function of the falling body | |
| Mathematical symbol | v of t | The velocity function | |
| Mathematical symbol | f prime of x | The derivative, in Newton’s prime notation | |
| Mathematical symbol | r of t | The distance of a planet from the Sun | |
| Mathematical symbol | nine point eight | The gravitational acceleration, in metres per second squared | |
| Mathematical symbol | g | The constant of gravitational acceleration |
