Comparison Property
The comparison property lets us bound integrals by comparing integrands.
Theorem
A theorem is a proposition that has been rigorously proved, and it is the foundation of mathematical reasoning. A theorem usually states its conditions and its conclusion, and is an important part of any mathematical system.
Let and be continuous on and on . Then
Example: Compare with
On we have , so the integrals satisfy as well.
Exercise 1
On we have . Use the comparison property to compare with , and evaluate both.
Approach: First justify the pointwise inequality by factoring the difference, which is non-negative on ; then apply the comparison property to obtain the ordering of the integrals, and finally evaluate both integrals exactly as a check.
Steps:
- On , , so holds.
- By the comparison property (both integrands are continuous on ): .
- Left side: .
- Right side: .
- The result agrees with the conclusion of the comparison property.
Answer: .
Exercise 2
On we have . Use the comparison property to compare with , and say whether the inequality is an equality.
Approach: The comparison property gives . Evaluate both integrals, then check whether the pointwise inequality is strict on the whole interval, which decides whether the integral inequality is strict as well.
Steps:
- On we have , with strict inequality for .
- By the comparison property: .
- Left side: .
- Right side: .
- Since for , the integral inequality is strict: . Equality would require on , which is plainly false.
Answer: , so the inequality is strict.
Exercise 3
Let be continuous on and suppose . Use the comparison property together with continuity to prove that there exists with .
Approach: Suppose never vanishes on . Continuity then forbids from taking both positive and negative values (otherwise the intermediate value theorem would give a zero), so is either positive everywhere or negative everywhere; the sign-preserving property (a direct consequence of the comparison property) then makes the integral strictly positive or strictly negative, contradicting the hypothesis.
Steps:
- Suppose, for a contradiction, that for every .
- If there were with , then would be continuous on the interval between and and would lie strictly between and , so the intermediate value theorem would give a with , contradicting the assumption. Hence is either positive everywhere on or negative everywhere there.
- If is positive everywhere, the sign-preserving property gives ; if is negative everywhere, it gives . Both contradict the hypothesis .
- The assumption is therefore false, and there exists with .
Answer: There exists such that .
Symbols Used in This Article
| Symbol | Type | Pronunciation/Explanation | Meaning in This Article |
|---|---|---|---|
| mathematical symbol | integral | Definite integral sign | |
| function symbol | f of x, g of x | The two continuous integrands whose integrals are compared | |
| mathematical symbol | integral from a to b of f of x | The smaller of the two integrals, on the left of the inequality | |
| mathematical symbol | integral from a to b of g of x | The larger of the two integrals, on the right of the inequality | |
| interval | closed interval | The interval on which both integrands are continuous | |
| mathematical symbol | x squared | The smaller integrand in the worked example | |
| mathematical symbol | x | The larger integrand in the worked example | |
| mathematical symbol | differential of x | The differential element of the integration variable |
